Tyrannis: Contest Ended

The window for entering CCP’s/Roc’s Tyrannis Contest is now officially closed. All entries have been received and posted, including a final batch of last minute entries I received late last night.

On behalf of the wonderful people at CCP and myself, thank you for your incredible interest in this contest. I think it’s safe to say everyone has quite a bit of quality reading to do over the next while thanks to all of you.

I’ve learned a few things during this contest, about contest management, expectations, fairness, etc, etc.

One of those things I would like to share with you is the notion of “popularity contests”.

It bothered me when someone commented that this was merely nothing more than a popularity contest. Upon giving it some thought, and digging around, I discovered they were right, and a solution was needed. I mean, even though I’m no longer part of the Tribal Liberation Force, I’m still a man of honour and want to make sure the right thing is always done.

To that end, I consulted with PyjamaSam, the smartest guy I know. With his help, we came up with an equation that gave greater weight to the star rating than the number of users, as well as a diminishing return penalty based on how many days the entry had been posted, as older entries had more chance of getting votes than new entries. This morning, as I started tallying results, the equation seems solid. Entries from even the last day are successfully competing against entries from the first days.

Another item that concerned me greatly was spam. Here I simply need to thank WordPress for their wonderful tools. It was easy to identify which posts were getting spam, and when re-reading a few emails sent to me, plus some of the comments on certain entries, I was quick to disqualify the spamming entrants.

So, while I take the next little while to get everything in order, double check the results, and sit back and relax for the first time in 18 days, know that I appreciate everyone’s efforts and all the hard work that went into your submissions.

PS. Not sure if anyone noticed yet, but the blog is now pointing to http://www.rocwieler.com. This is all part of an initiative I am starting with the next issue of EON magazine. There has been a lot of change in my life lately, and I think that needs to be reflected.

Here’s a sneak peek of the upcoming ad, and HERE is a link to the desktop wallpaper version.

11 responses to “Tyrannis: Contest Ended

  1. Thanks for the contest and good luck to all entries. The only thing I wonder is about diminishing returns for older posts… There were a ton of entries, some longer then most… So even though I personaly tried to read a majority there were alot that slipped by in the
    mix, getting buried under newer stories. So what of those great stories that didn’t get ratings because of that? Just a thought. Either way writing my entry was fun and I feel like keeping the story going, so thank you roc for that! I look forward to the next contest.

    • The diminishing return value weight was not substantial enough to seriously impact the results thus far.

      Sam is brilliant smart. I know he took every aspect of fairness into consideration.

      • Cool, yea was just curious as to how it was working in that particular case…

        I know how these things can be a logistics nightmare. Thanks again

  2. It’s ended already O.o? well… thank you roc for this oppurtunity to write about the sci-fi universe I’ve always admired. and thanks to CCP for making the game sooooo great!

    *kccht* Steven out…*kccht*

  3. There have not been any feeds to the iPhone capsuleers… Not recently. FYI. Looking forward to reading more.

Leave a Reply to Nick Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.